A. WAR CRIMES TRIALS
| PL-184/1.1. |
U.S. v. Goering
6 FRD 69 (1946); (Trial of Major War Criminals Before Int'l Military Tribunal (IMT), Germany 1947)
1932-45: Defs led Third Reich. 1943: U.S., France, UK, USSR announced they would punish war criminals after Allied victory. 5/8/45: Allies defeated Germany, ending WWII in Europe. 8/7/45: U.S., France, UK, USSR executed London Agreement and Charter setting forth crimes against peace, crimes against humanity, war crimes. 11/14/45: U.S., USSR, UK, France Tribunal indicted 24 Defs pursuant to London Agreement and Charter. Count 1: conspiracy to commit crimes against peace, war crimes, crimes against humanity. Count 2: crimes against peace, including waging wars of aggression in violation of Conventions for Pacific Settlement of Int'l Disputes (1899, 1907); Hague Convention III re Opening of Hostilities (1907); Versailles Treaty (1919); Kellogg-Briand Pact (1928). Count 3: war crimes in violation of int'l conventions, internal penal laws, including murder of civilian population, torture, genocide, deportation of civilian population for slave labor (France-1,408,000; Belgium-190,000; Holland-500,000; USSR-4,978,000), murder of POWs, killing of hostages, plunder of public, private property causing starvation in occupied countries, destruction of works of art, 6,000,000 buildings leaving 25,000,000 homeless, wanton devastation not justified by military necessity, Germanization of occupied territories. Count 4: crimes against humanity including murder, extermination, enslavement, deportation of civilian populations, persecution on political, racial, religious grounds. Defs pleaded not guilty: trial under ex post facto law, unfairly conducted by non-neutrals.
• Tribunal rejected Defs' motions. Judges appointed by signatories of Charter of IMT: Lord Justice Lawrence and Mr Justice Birkett, member and alternate for UK; Francis Biddle and Judge John J Parker, member and alternate for U.S.; M Le Professeur Donneidieu de Vabres and M Le Conseiller R Falco, member and alternate for France; Major General I T Nikitchenko and Lt Col A F Volchkov, member and alternate for USSR. Evidence on both sides consisted of witnesses, documents captured by Allied armies in German Army headquarters, including correspondence to, from Hitler, other members of Third Reich. 11/45-10/46: Trial. Ct found: 3 Defs not guilty; 8 guilty of count 1; 12 guilty of count 2; 16 guilty of count 3; 16 guilty of count 4. Sentences: 12 to death; 3 to life; 2 to 20 yrs; 1 to 15 yrs; 1 to 10 yrs. Soviet members diss: Hess should receive death instead of life in prison, should be finding Hitler's Cabinet, Gen'l Staff, Army High Command to be criminal organizations.
|
War Crimes |
| PL-464/1.2. |
UK v. Tesch
(Zyklon B Case)
I Law Reports of Trials of War Criminals 93 (London, 1947); II Laws of War: A Documentary History 1284, 1487, 1498
3 Defs-scientists provided prussic acid for use in concentration camps.
• 3/46: Before British Military Tribunal, Defs argued lack of specific knowledge of use of acid in lethal dosages for criminal purposes. 1946: Tribunal convicted Tesch, Weinbacher; acquitted Drosihn: Defs could not plead ignorance of purpose; civilian accessory to violation of laws, customs of war liable as war criminal. Sentence: Death.
|
War Crimes |
| PL-512/1.2. |
U.S. v. Araki
(Tokyo Judgment, Int'l Military Tribunal for Far East (IMTFE)); 4/29/46-11/12/48, IMTFE Vols I, II, (1977); Transcript of Proceedings, 4/29/46-4/16/48, Vols 1-113, pp 1-48, 412; Narrative Summary, 6/14/46-1/12/48, Vols 1-14; IMTFE Prosecution Summation Vols 1-7; IMTFE Defense Summation Vols 1-16; Analysis of Documentary Evidence Vols 1-29; Exhibits Nos 1-3915; habeas corpus pet den 338 US 197 (1948)
1/1/28-9/2/45: Japanese Defs waged aggressive war against Allies — U.S., UK, China, USSR, Australia, N Zealand, Canada, France, Netherlands, India, Philippines — to gain political/economic domination of E Asia, Pacific, Indian Oceans, bordering countries. U.S. Joint Chiefs of Staff ordered Gen'l MacArthur, Supreme Commander for Allied Powers in Japan, to issue IMTFE Charter as exec decree. Allies convened IMTFE, appointed 10 judges from 10 nations. 4/29/46: IMTFE indicted 28 Japanese Defs (highest gov't/military officials 1/28-9/45) on 55 counts under IMTFE Charter; Potsdam Declaration, cl 8; Instrument of Surrender; Cairo Declaration; Covenant of League of Nations; Kellogg-Briand Pact; Convention for Pacific Settlement of Disputes (1899, 1907); Neutrality Pact between USSR, Japan (1941), Arts I, II; domestic laws of countries where crimes committed. Counts 1-36: crimes against peace (conspiring to wage wars of aggression against Asia, China, U.S., USSR, UK, France). Counts 37-52: murdering civilians, military personnel (2,015,000 Chinese, more than 118,442 Filipinos); Defs maiming, ill-treating, murdering POWs, civilian internees, denying food, shelter, medical care, caging, drowning, burying alive (in "rape of Nanking" 260-300,000 Chinese men, women, children died); forcing POWs, civilian internees into slave labor, conducting "death marches" (in Bataan death march thousands died); Defs perpetrated murder, rape, pillage, brigandage, torture on civilian populations (bombing/bayoneting); wanton destruction of towns, villages. Counts 53-55: conventional war crimes, crimes against humanity. 5/6/46: All Defs pleaded not guilty, challenged IMTFE jurisdiction: aggressive war not per se illegal; war is act of nation for which no individual responsible under int'l law; IMTFE Charter "ex post facto"; killings in course of belligerent operations normal incidents of warfare, not illegal except when violate rules of warfare. 5/46: IMTFE dism'd Defs' motion re jurisdiction.
• 6/3/46-1/24/47: Ch Prosecutor Kennan (U.S.), prosecutors from 11
nations presented evidence: Defs, others conspired to gain control of Japanese gov't, prepared, indoctrinated Japanese "for program of aggressive warfare;" Defs conspired w/ rulers of Nazi Germany, Fascist Italy to secure political, economic domination of world; Defs waged war of aggression against U.S. in bombing Pearl Harbor. 2/24/47-1/12/48: Defs presented evidence: No substantial evidence showing any Def individually, or in concert, engaged in conspiracy; conspiracy law has no application to official actions; offenses or moral standards defined in vague terms — no intent, most Defs charged w/ acts of omission while serving in highest civil/military offices; Defs' acts were acts of Japanese gov't in sovereign capacity; Defs not answerable under body of law, nat'l or int'l; neither Potsdam Declaration nor Japanese Instrument of Surrender established nat'l or int'l law; Kellogg-Briand Pact did not compromise right of self-defense: nation believing war needed for self-defense might be aggressor in fact, but not breaker of treaty; Japan never ratified Geneva Convention re Treatment of POWs; 1907 Hague Convention re opening of hostilities has no application to situations involving war of self-defense because evidence of prosecution shows U.S., UK, USSR engaged in de facto state of war w/ Japan prior to 12/7/41, by economic/military assistance to China during Sino-Japanese hostilities. No int'l law defines crime of murder; no proof any Def committed murder; no precedent that heads of gov'ts of sovereign nations guilty of murder by legal or extra-legal activities on part of armed forces of sovereign nation. No proof Defs knowingly or intentionally committed conventional war crimes against humanity. 11/4/48-12/48: IMTFE, Pres Webb, pronounced judgment: All Defs guilty; sentences: 7 to death; 15 to life; 1 to 20 yrs; 3 died during trial; 1 declared insane. 5 JJ dissented wholly or in part, 2 re nature of punishment. 12/48: Several Defs filed motions for leave to file petitions for writs of habeas corpus w/ USSC. 12/20/48: USSC denied Defs' motions. Sentences carried out.
|
War Crimes |
| PL-515/1.3. |
U.S. v. Krupp
(Krupp Case)
(U.S. Military Tribunal, Nuremberg); 9 Trials of War Criminals 1327 (1950)
12/43: Under Lex Krupp, Hitler decree, Fried Krupp AG, private co, converted into individually-owned firm of Fried Krupp, in sole ownership of Def-Krupp, who appointed 11 other Defs to management positions w/in co. Since 1943, unincorporated, privately-owned concern owned/controlled directly, as well as through subsidiary holding cos, mines, steel, armament plants, shipyards, machinery factories used in war effort. 1945: After defeat of Nazis, Allied Control Council (U.S., USSR, UK, France) enacted Control Council Law #10. 8/16/47: U.S. filed indictment: Count 1: planning, preparation, initiation, waging aggressive war. Count 2: plunder, spoliation of territories occupied by German armed forces in ruthless way beyond needs of army, in disregard of needs of local economy, Hague Regulations Arts 46-56 (1907), Control Council Law #10, Art II. Count 3: crimes re POWs, slave labor, Hague Rules of Land Warfare. Count 4: common plan/conspiracy to commit crimes against peace. Defs pleaded not
guilty, asserted necessity defense, filed motion for judgment of not guilty on 1, 4: evidence insufficient as matter of law to warrant judgment.
• 12/9/47-6/9/48: Trial tribunal heard oral testimony of 117 prosecution, defense witnesses, 134 witnesses examined before commrs, prosecution introduced 1,471 docs, defense introduced 2,829 docs. 3/5/48: Tribunal, Daly, Presiding J, granted Defs' motion as to counts 1, 4: prosecution failed to prove case beyond reasonable doubt. 7/48: Tribunal found: 6 Defs guilty on count 2; 10 on count 3. Sentences: 7 to 9-12 yrs; 2 to 6-7 yrs, 1 to 2 yrs.
|
War Crimes |
| PL-514/1.4. |
U.S. v. Krauch
(IG Farben Case)
(U.S. Military Tribunal VI, U.S. Zone of Occupancy, Nuremberg, Case #6); VII, VIII Trials of War Criminals Before Nuremberg Military Tribunals (1952)
5/3/47: U.S. Military Tribunal VI indicted 23 leading German industrialists on 5 counts: Count 1: crimes against peace through planning, preparation, initiation, waging wars of aggression, invasions in other countries. Offenses include: IG Farben allied w/ Hitler, Nazi Party; synchronized activities w/ military planning of German high command; cooperated w/ Hitler to build up military machine violating Versailles Treaty; participated in Germany's 4-yr plan for economic mobilization for war; created, equipped Nazi military machine for war; procured, stockpiled critical war materials (oil, lead, magnesium, etc) for Nazi offenses; participated in weakening enemies; carried on propaganda, intelligence, espionage; Defs participated in plunder, spoliation, slavery, mass murder as part of wars of aggression. Defs violated int'l law, treaties, agreements, assurances, Control Council Law #10, Art II. Count 2: Plunder, spoliation; Defs participated in plunder of public, private property in countries which came under belligerent occupation of Germany; Defs marched w/ Wehrmacht, played major role in Germany's plans for conquest; Defs conceived, initiated, prepared plans for German acquisition of chemical industries in Austria, Czechoslovakia, Poland, Norway, France, Russia, etc. (violated laws, customs of war, int'l treaties, conventions, 1907 Hague Convention, Regs, Arts 45-56, 1131, gen'l principles of criminal law, internal penal laws of countries where crimes committed, Control Council Law No 10, Art II). Count 3: war crimes, crimes against humanity: participating in enslavement, forced labor of civilian population of countries occupied or controlled by Germany, enslavement of concentration camp inmates w/in Germany, use of POWs in illegal labor. Defs charged w/ mistreatment, terrorization, torture, murder of enslaved persons. Count 4: Defs Schneider, Buetefisch, von der Heyde charged w/ membership in criminal org. Count 5: conspiracy to commit crimes against peace. 8/14/47: Defs pleaded not guilty.
• 8/27/47-5/12/48: Defs tried by U.S. military tribunal. Tribunal acquitted (2-1) all Defs on Counts 1, 4, 5; convicted all on Count 2; convicted some, acquitted others on Count 3 (dissenter argued sufficient evidence to convict all Defs for mass murder, slavery). Sentences: 1½ to 8 yrs.
|
War Crimes |
| PL-191/1.5. |
U.S. v. Brandt
(Medical Case)
(U.S. Military Tribunal I, U.S. Zone of Occupancy, Nuremberg, Case #1, 1947); I, II Trials of War Criminals Before Nuremberg Military Tribunals Under Control Council Law #10 (1949); cert den 333 US 836 (1948); Frontline, PBS series (2/24/87)
1939-45: 23 Defs, including doctors, held key positions in Third Reich. 10/25/46: U.S. indicted Defs on 4 counts: 1) conspiracy to commit war crimes; 2) war crimes; 3) crimes against humanity, including experimentation on concentration camp victims (eg, high-altitude, freezing, mustard gas, poison experiments); 4) membership in criminal org under 1907 Hague Regs, Arts 4-7, 46; 1929 Geneva POW Convention, Arts 2-4; laws, customs of war; gen'l principles of criminal law; internal penal laws of countries in which crimes committed; Control Council Law #10, Art II (1945). Defs argued: not implicated in experiments due to limited powers, specific duties; superior orders freed them from criminal responsibility; participation in experiments was voluntary; medical experiments took place due to military necessity, nat'l emergency; killings justified because victims were spies; experiments were substitutes for punishments previously imposed; experiments furthered medical science.
• 1947: Beals, Presiding J (ChJ, WA Sup Ct), Sebring, J (Associate J, FL Sup Ct), Crawford, J (OK DJ): Ct lacked jurisdiction on Count 1; 7 Defs not guilty; 1 guilty on Count 6; 6 guilty on Counts 2, 3; 9 guilty on Counts 2, 3, 5. Sentences: 7 to death; 5 to life; 3 to 20, 15, 10 years. 16 Defs petitioned Military Gov Clay for clemency; 15 petitioned USSC for writs of habeas corpus, prohibition against proceeding or order nullifying trial. Clay denied pet. 1948: USSC denied cert. U.S. High Commr John McCloy commuted 9 Defs' sentences. Drs Siegfried Ruff, Konrad Schaeffer among those acquitted. 1947: Pentagon brought 4 Defs to U.S. to work on space/high-altitude programs as part of Project Paperclip, under which 400 Nazi scientists brought to U.S. To bypass immigration law barring Nazis, Sec'y of War Patterson, Sec'y of State Acheson, Asst Sec'y of State Gen'l Hildring gave military right to authorize immigration; U.S. military cleaned scientists' records of references to SS, Nazi Party.
|
War Crimes |
| PL-516/1.5. |
U.S. v. List
(Hostages Case)
(U.S. Military Tribunal, Nuremberg, 2/48); 11 Trial of War Criminals 1230 (1950)
1946: U.S. Military Tribunal indicted German Defs-Field Marshals List, von Weichs; Gen'ls Rendulic, Kuntze, Foertsch, Boehme, Felmy, Lanz, Dehner, von Leyser, Speidel, von Geitner, commanders of German Mountain Forces, armed forces in SE: war crimes, crimes against humanity under Control Council Law #10. Count 1: killed, tortured 100,000 civilians labelled "partisans", "Communists" in Greece, Albania, Yugoslavia, as retaliation for military attacks on Germans; ordered 100 "hostages" killed for every German soldier killed, 50 "hostages" killed for every German soldier wounded. Count 2:
Plundered, destroyed cities/farms/villages in Greece, Yugoslavia, Albania, Norway w/ no military necessity. Count 3: Denied enemy troops POW status/rights; executed prisoners; held relatives of soldiers in Greece, Yugoslavia, Italy nat'l armies responsible for members' acts of war. Count 4: Forced labor, slave labor, concentration camps, murder, terrorization of civilian populations of Greece, Yugoslavia, Albania. Acts charged violated 1907 Hague Regs, gen'l criminal law principles, penal laws of countries where crimes committed; Control Council Law #10 declared, recognized, defined acts as crimes. All Defs pleaded not guilty except Boehme, who committed suicide before arraignment.
• 1948: After trial before Wennerstrum, Presiding J: 1) Yugoslavia, Greece were occupied; 2) partisan troops failed to observe laws, customs of war, exercised guerrilla warfare against occupiers, thus not lawful belligerents, not entitled to POW treatment; 3) term "hostage" used inappropriately; 4) Defs' acts were reprisals; military necessity does not justify violation of positive law, thus not valid defense to Defs' arbitrary, excessive reprisals; convicted 8 Defs; sentences: 2 to life, 2 to 20 yrs, 1 each to 15, 12, 10, 7 yrs; acquitted 2 Defs.
|
War Crimes |
| PL-193/1.6. |
U.S. v. Ohlendorf
(Einsatzgruppen Case)
(U.S. Military Tribunal II, U.S. Zone of Occupancy, Nuremberg, Case #9, 1948); IV Trials of War Criminals before Nuremberg Military Tribunals (1946); cert den 336 US 964 (1946)
5/41: 24 Defs held high posts in Einsatzgruppen (special task forces) formed before German attack on USSR to accompany German Army into occupied East to exterminate Jews, gypsies, Soviet officials, others. 7/9/47: U.S. charged Defs on 3 counts. Count 1: crimes against humanity, including murder, extermination, imprisonment, genocide, constituting violations of law of nations, int'l conventions, general principles of criminal law, internal penal laws of countries in which crimes were committed, Control Council Law #10, Art II. Count 2: war crimes including murder, torture of POWs, civilians, wanton destruction not justified by military necessity, violating 1907 Hague Convention #IV Regs, Arts 43, 46; 1929 Geneva POW Convention; laws, customs of war. Count 3: membership in criminal orgs so declared in Control Council Law #10, Art II. Defs argued: superior orders, no means of refusing orders; orders justified because they believed Jews were Nazi enemies, bearers of bolshevism; since Allies killed large numbers of German civilians w/out being charged, Defs also should not be charged; killings constituted death penalties for illegal partisan activities or reprisal measures justified under int'l law; evidence submitted by prosecution inaccurate. 7/31/47: Def Haussmann committed suicide.
• 4/8/48: Mussmanno, Presiding J (Member, U.S. Naval Reserve on military leave from Ct of Common Pleas, Allegheny Co, PA), Speight, J (member, AL bar), Dixon, J, found: all Defs guilty on count 3; 20 guilty on counts 1, 2. Sentences: 14 to death; 2 to life; 3 to 20 yrs; 2 to 10 yrs. 3/4/49: U.S. Military Gov Clay aff'd sentences. 5/2/49: USSC denied Defs' petitions to modify sentences.
|
Crimes Against Humanity |
| PL-195/1.7. |
U.S. v. Milch
(U.S. Military Tribunal II, U.S. Zone of Occupancy, Nuremberg, Case #2, 1947); II Trials of War Criminals before Nuremberg Military Tribunals 355 (1946); 332 US 789 (1947)
1939-45: Def held top Third Reich posts. 11/13/46: U.S. indicted Def: Count 1: war crimes involving deportation to slave labor of civilian populations of Austria, Czechoslovakia, Italy, Hungary resulting in enslavement, torture, murder of millions; war operations including transportation of arms in course of which murders, other inhumane acts committed, constituting violations of 1907 Hague Regs, Arts 4-7, 46, 52; 1929 Geneva POW Convention, Arts 2-4, 6, 31; laws, customs of war, general principles of criminal law, internal penal laws of countries in which crimes committed, Control Council Law #10, Art II. Count 2: war crimes involving medical experiments on humans resulting in murder, torture, in violation of Hague Regs Arts 4-7, 46; POW Convention, Arts 2-4. Count 3: Crimes against humanity consisting of acts in counts 1, 2. Def argued: lacked knowledge of war crimes due to superior's mistrust in Def; documents submitted as evidence inaccurate.
• 4/16/47: Toms, Presiding J (CJ, Detroit, MI), Phillips, J (NC Super Ct) Musmanno, J (Ct Common Pleas, Allegheny Co, PA) found Def guilty on counts 1, 3; not guilty on 2. Sentence: life. 5/2/47: Military Gov denied Def's petition for clemency. 10/20/47: USSC (4-4) denied habeas petition.
|
Crimes Against Humanity |
| PL-212/1.7. |
U.S. v. Greifelt
(RuSHA Case)
(U.S. Military Tribunal I, U.S. Zone of Occupancy, Nuremberg, Case #8, 1948); IV, V Trials of War Criminals before Nuremberg Military Tribunals 599 (1946)
7/1/47: U.S. indicted 14 leading officials of German Race and Settlement Main Office ("RuSHA"), 3 other SS agencies. Count 1: crimes against humanity involving acts carried out as part of systematic program of genocide including kidnapping children of foreign nat'ls to select for Germanization those considered to be of "racial value", exterminating those born of eastern workers in Germany; compelling abortions on eastern workers; hampering reproduction of enemy nat'ls; executing, imprisoning, Germanizing eastern workers who had sexual intercourse w/ Germans, imprisoning Germans involved; evacuating enemy populations from native lands, resettling land w/ ethnic Germans; compelling nat'ls of other nations to perform work in Germany, become members of German community, join German Armed Forces; persecution, extermination of Jews in violation of 1907 Hague Regs, Arts 4-7, 23, 43, 45-47, 52, 56; laws, customs of war; general principles of criminal law; internal penal laws of countries in which crimes committed; Control Council Law #10, Art II. Count 2: war crimes including plunder of public, private property, murder, extermination, enslavement, deportation, imprisonment, torture; violation of Hague Regs; 1929 POW Convention; other laws in count 1. Count 3: membership in criminal org. Defs argued: acted under
superior orders; legal concept of genocide had not yet been formulated by authoritative int'l orgs at time of acts, so ex post facto; Poland lost sovereignty to Germany in 1939, therefore German law was legally binding on Defs; contested validity of parts of Hague Regs.
• 3/10/48: Wyatt, Presiding J (Assoc J, GA Sup Ct), O'Connell, J (Associate J, MA Sup Ct), Crawford, J (OK DJ): 13 Defs guilty on count 3; 7 guilty on counts 1, 2; 1 not guilty. Sentences: 2 Defs to 25 yrs; 1 to 20 yrs; 3 to 15 yrs; 1 to 10 yrs; 5 to time served. U.S. Military Gov Clay aff'd all sentences. 5/2/49: USSC denied writ of habeas corpus to 6 Defs.
|
Crimes Against Humanity |
| PL-465/1.8. |
U.S. v. Flick
(U.S. Military Tribunal, Nuremberg, 1948); II Laws of War: A Documentary History 1284, 1487
2/48: Defs-German industrial leaders indicted on 5 counts: participation in Third Reich slave-labor program; spoliation of public, private property in occupied territories; crimes against humanity; knowledge of Himmler's criminal activities; contributing to/membership in SS. Defs argued int'l law outside work, interest, knowledge of private individuals.
• Tribunal convicted 3; acquitted 3: int'l law binds every citizen just as does municipal law; criminal acts by Gov't official are criminal when done by private individual; Gov't crime differs only in magnitude, not quality. Sentences: 2½-7 yrs.
|
Crimes Against Humanity |
| PL-466/1.8. |
U.S. v. Weizsaeker
(Ministries Case)
(U.S. Military Tribunal, Nuremberg, 1948); 14 Trial of War Criminals, 308 (1952); II Laws of War: A Documentary History 1248, 1487, 1498
11/18/47: Indictment filed against 19 Defs-officials in Foreign Ministry, other branches of Nazi Gov't: 8 counts of crimes against peace, crimes against humanity, participating in common plan, conspiracy to commit crimes against peace. 1/7/48: Presentation of evidence.
• Tribunal convicted Defs on 1-5 of 8 counts: liability extends to lower officials who aided in implementation of Nazi policies w/ knowledge of their nature. Sentences: 4-20 yrs.
|
Crimes Against Humanity |
| PL-196/1.8. |
UK v. Killinger
(Dulag Luft Trial)
(British Military Ct for Trials of War Crimes at Wuppertal, 1945); IX War Crimes Trials, Dulag Luft Trial (1952)
1943-45: Defs-Commandant, Chief Interrogator, officer in charge of admr, 2 ordinary interrogators at Third Reich's Dulag Luft POW camp in Germany. Prosecution alleged Defs extracted information from Allied airmen by torture. 11/26/45: Britain indicted Defs: crimes against laws of war, including 1929 Geneva Convention, Arts 2, 5. Defs argued: not culpable for crimes committed under superiors' orders; argued prosecution's evidence inaccurate.
• Judgment by 3 British military officials: 3 Defs guilty; 2 not guilty. Sentences: 2 to 5 yrs; 1 to 1 yr.
|
War Crimes |
| PL-198/1.9. |
UK v. Zuess
(Natzweiler Trial)
(British Military Ct for Trials of War Crimes at Wuppertal); V War Crimes Trials, Natzweiler Trial (1949)
4/6/44: 4 female British POWs at Natzweiler concentration camp in Alsace, w/out h'g or trial, killed by injection of poison, immediately cremated. 5/29/46: Britain indicted 9 Defs-camp officials: war crimes, crimes against humanity under 1945 London Agreement and Charter, 1907 Hague Regs. Defs argued: not present at executions, no knowledge of crimes; acts were lawful execution of spies.
• Judgment by 3 British military officials: 6 guilty, 3 not guilty. Sentences: 1 to death; 1 to life; 1 to 13 yrs; 1 to 10 yrs; 1 to 5 yrs; 1 to 4 yrs.
See Killinger, PL-196/1.8
|
War Crimes |
| PL-211/1.9. |
UK v. von Falkenhorst
(British Military Ct for Trial of War Crimes at Brunswick, 1946); VI War Crimes Trials, The Falkenhorst Trial (1949)
1940-44: Def-Commander in Chief of German armed forces in Norway. 10/26/42: Def followed orders to: refuse to quarter Allied military personnel, kill them after capture. Britain indicted Def: 9 charges of ordering prisoners to be killed, specific cases in which prisoners killed in violation of laws, customs of war as found in int'l laws, laws of individual nations. Def argued he acted under superior orders.
• Judgment by 3 British military officials: Def guilty of 7 charges, acquitted of 2. Sentence: death.
|
War Crimes |
| PL-513/1.9. |
Yamashita v. Styer
(Appeal of Tomoyuki Yamashita before USSC)
327 US 1 (1946); IV, B UN War Crimes Comm, Law Reports of Trials of War Criminals 75-96
10/9/44-9/2/45: Def-Commanding Gen'l, 14th Army Group, Imperial Japanese Army, Philippines. 9/3/45: Def surrendered, became POW of U.S. Armed Forces in Philippines. 9/25/45: U.S. Army Lt Gen'l Wilhelm Styer charged Def, while commander of armed forces of Japan at war w/ U.S./allies, for unlawfully disregarding/failing to discharge duty as commander to control operations of members of command, permitting brutal atrocities against people of U.S./allies, particularly Philippines, violating laws of war: 1) starvation, execution/massacre w/out trial, maladministration of civilian internees/POWs; 2) torture, rape, murder, mass execution of over 25,000 Filipino men, women, children, including members of religious orders, by starvation, beheading, bayoneting, clubbing, hanging, burning alive, destruction by explosives; 3) burning/demolition w/out adequate military necessity of large numbers of homes, businesses, hospitals, religious, educational institutions. 10/8/45: Def pleaded not guilty; moved to dismiss for failure to state violation of laws of war.
• 10/29-12/7/45: Military commn-5 U.S. Army officers appointed by Styer tried Def. 12/7/45: Commn found Def guilty, sentence: death by
hanging. 11/28/45: Def filed petitions for habeas corpus/prohibition to Philippines Sup Ct: detention unlawful, military commn w/out jurisdiction because: 1) no military commn could lawfully be convened after cessation of hostilities between armed forces of U.S., Japan; 2) failed to charge Def w/ violation of law of war; 3) order governing procedure/commn's rulings permitted admission in evidence of depositions, affidavits, hearsay, opinion evidence in violation of Arts of War 25, 38 (10 USC §§1496, 1509), Geneva Convention (47 Stat 2021), 5th Amdt due process; 4) failed to give advance notice of trial to neutral power representing Japan's interests as belligerent required by Geneva Convention Art 60. 11/28/45: Philippine Sup Ct denied petitions: jurisdiction limited to inquiry re military commn's jurisdiction to put Pet on trial; found jurisdiction. 12/17/45: Writs forwarded, reviewed by USSC. 2/4/46: USSC aff'd (6-2), Stone, ChJ: denied cert: 1) U.S. Cong recognized "military commission" appointed by military command as appropriate tribunal for trial/punishment of offenses of law of war (1917 Espionage Act, 50 USC §38; Arts of War §§2, 12, 15, 10 USC §§1473, 1483, 1486; U.S. Const, Art 1, §8, cl 10; 317 US 1); 2) such tribunals not cts whose rulings subject to review by USSC ( 17 L Ed 589; 179 US 126; supra); 3) end of hostilities does not preclude trial of offenders before military commn, at least until peace officially recognized by treaty: Art of War 15, 10 USC §1486; U.S. Const, Art 1, §8, cl 10; 4) Commanding gen'l had affirmative duty to take measures to protect POWs from violations of law of war while Japanese forces occupied Philippines: Annex to 1907 4th Hague Convention, Arts 1, 43; 10th Hague Convention, Art 19. Rutledge, Murphy, JJ, diss: 1) Def denied protection of 5th Amdt due process, charged w/ legally unrecognized war crime; 2) Def given insufficient time to prepare; 3) Commn's findings did not prove Def had knowledge of widespread atrocities, crimes; 4) U.S. violated Geneva Convention Art 60 by not notifying neutral power representing Japan's interests as belligerent in advance of trial. 2/23/46: U.S. hanged Def in Manila, Philippines.
U.S.-Solicitor Gen'l J Howard McGrath; Pet-Capt A Frank Reel, JAGD
|
War Crimes |
| PL-511/1.10. |
Supreme Soviet of USSR v Otozoo
(Materials on Former Servicemen of Japanese Army charged w/ Manufacturing/Employing Bacteriological Weapons, Moscow, 1950)
1934: Following secret order by Emperor Hirohito, Japan's General Staff/Ministry for War set up 2 units for manufacture of bacteriological weapons for Kwantung Army to carry out goal of creating "Greater East Asia Co-Prosperity Sphere," including China, Soviet Far East, Netherlands, India, Afghanistan, Australia, New Zealand, Philippines, etc. 1934-1945: 12 Defs (including high officials, doctors, veterinarians) participated in production of bacteriological weapons for use in warfare, chiefly against USSR: bred germs of plague, cholera, gas gangrene, anthrax, typhoid, paratyphoid, etc; conducted inhuman experiments on Chinese, Soviet POWs; shot or injected male/female
POWs w/ lethal bacteria, potassium cyanide. Army Detachments manufactured bacteria bombs, walking sticks, fountain pens to disperse in USSR, China. 1945: Defs sprayed/bombed lethal germs, released fleas, rodents, other animals infected w/ germs into inhabited localities, wells, crops, livestock in China, areas contiguous to USSR causing plague, cholera, other epidemics to kill millions of civilians, troops. 12/16/49: Presidium, Supreme Soviet, USSR indicted 12 Defs-Kwantung Army members, under Decree Art 1: supervising production of bacteriological weapons for use against USSR, other states; allowing/engaging in criminal bacteriological experiments on people; active bacteriological warfare against China, bacteriological sabotage against USSR.
• 12/25-30/49: Primorye Military Area Military Tribunal tried Defs. All 12 Defs pleaded guilty; some expressed remorse; some said following superior orders. Judgment: guilty; sentences to labor correction camps: 4 Defs to 25 yrs; 2 to 20 yrs; 4 to 10-18 yrs; 2 to 2-3 yrs.
|
War Crimes |
| PL-517a/1.11. |
USSR v. Fedorenko
(Crimean Regional Ct, Simferopol, Ukraine); (USSR Supreme Soviet)
1942-43: Def-guard, Treblinka concentration camp. 1949: Def entered U.S. 1970: Def became U.S. citizen. 6/28/79: 5th Cir revoked citizenship. 1/21/81: USSC (7-2) Marshall, J, aff'd revocation. 12/19/84: USSC, Brennan, Stevens, JJ, rejected appeals. 12/21/84: U.S. deported Def to USSR, arrested: treason.
• 6/10/86: Regional Ct trial commenced. 6/19/86: Tyutyunnik, J: Def guilty of treason, voluntarily aiding Nazi forces during WWII, participating in mass execution of civilians; sentence: death. Def applied for mercy. Ukrainian presidium, Supreme Soviet denied. Presidium, USSR Supreme Soviet denied. 7/27/87: Def executed by firing squad.
See PL-517/42.6
|
War Crimes |
| PL-518/1.11. |
France v. Alois Brunner
(Paris Ct 1954); (Marseilles Ct 1954)
1940s: Austrian Adolf Eichmann ordered, carried out deportation to concentration camps of 130,000 Jews from France, Austria, Greece, Czechoslovakia. World Jewish Cong charged Def-Austrian: acting under Eichmann's command.
• 1954: Paris, Marseilles Cts tried Def in absentia; convicted; sentence: death. 1983: Germany asked Syria to extradite Def; Syria denied Def in Syria. 12/17/88: French Foreign Ministry sent request for extradition to Syria: Def living there under false name. 7/18/91: French J Jean-Pierre Getti signed legal request for Syria to aid in identification of Def. 8/91: Germany, France agreed jointly to seek extradition of Def. Syria continued to deny Def's presence. 9/12/91: European Parliament passed resolution (219-0, 1 abstention) suggesting 12 EC Gov'ts launch joint initiative to persuade Syria to expel Def. Pending.
Roland Weyl, Paris, France
|
War Crimes |
|